", Leeper said, "Kessler is the person who knows where Jolene is and, unfortunately, she has not provided that information," Leeper said. At least two of Kimberly Kesslers aliases reportedly came from headstones in Butler. We were hoping to see Joleen get out of that vehicle, but who do you think it was? Now, theyre suspicious and really feel like they need to speak with Jennifer. And this is when things get really weird. Its a mothers worst nightmare. Its possible that Kimberly did not want her true identity exposed. Her Friends Want Them to Stay with People They Know, Hacksaw, Hatchet and Bloody Rug Found at Trash Site During Search for Missing Mass. She was last seen leaving her job on at Tangles hair salon, May 12, 2018. He says she should often appear to kind but would snap if triggered. " We are so desperate to find her.". Out of pure bad luck, Samantha, unfortunately, got in the vehicle of an absolute psychopath. Investigators unraveled Kessler's apparent double life when they began investigating Cummings' disappearance. "Our hearts are also broken for her mother, children and the rest of her family," the statement said. Basically, her mom waited 8 years to report her missing. kidnapping and killing Joleen Cummings, a mother of three, last year. She said she should have burned her finger prints off, said the cellmate. "Investigators have reviewed hundreds of hours of video surveillance from businesses and have been searching through phone records to find any clues as to where Joleen might be," the sheriff said. One interviewer was David Trempus, who was contacted by Kessler through Facebook, according to the interviews. Kessler was given multiple opportunities to testify during her trial, but she was removed because of what CBS affiliate WJAX called "routine outbursts. Sheriff Leeper said deputies had sought to speak with Kessler, aka Sybert, because she was believed to be the last person seen with Cummings, but she failed to show up for work that Monday. After that, everyone was afraid of her. The outcome of the trial has been highly debated and is controversial. You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. Kessler, 50, is now being held on a charge of grand theft auto after authorities said she was seen driving Cummings car after she disappeared. 18 aliases and 33 cities later, she is apprehended. This is the survival story of Ashley Reeves, a 17-year-old young woman who was savagely attacked by a teacher. Mom of 2, stabbed 8 times, is making most of second chance at life, Whose leak is it anyway? departments of labor, health and human services, education, and related agencies appropriations for 2022 117th congress (2021-2022) Her mother reported her missing in 2004 in Butler County, Pennsylvania. He had worked his way up to a triple homicide by stalking a young woman, even going as far as to live in the walls of their home. Girl Madalina Cojocari 'Not Telling Us Everything They Know': Police, Husband of Missing Pa. The flyer said she used the alias of Pamela Kleber or Kleiber. Kessler revealed she was born in 1968 and grew up in Butler, Pennsylvania. Tim Barnes dated her in the 1990s while she lived in Pennsylvania. Johnson, Cummings mother, had made an emotional appeal Tuesday night for anyone with information to come forward. However, what she did with the hand she was given has inspired other victims to speak up and share their own stories. She dropped from an intake weight of 196 lbs to a low of 74 lbs and would look pretty much like a sunken-eyed skeleton in our proceedings. Camerons wife, Stacy, is out shopping for Christmas presents at a thrift shop. Kimberly Kessler/ Jennifer Sybert cutting hair. Dr . She is actually Kimberly Kessler, the viscous and violent woman who had been reported missing by her mother 14 years ago in Pennsylvania. Emergency Medicine, Family Medicine (4) 28 years exp . Also, she reportedly used several fake drivers licenses. As the search carries on in Nassau, Duval and St. Johns counties by ground, air and water, her mother issued another impassioned plea for any information on her daughter. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Kimberly Lee Kessler missing July 4, 2004 from Butler, Butler County, now goes by Jennifer Sybert. That same day, authorities said, they went to the salon to speak with Kessler, but she didn't show up to work from that point forward and the address she had given to her boss was fake. On May 12th, 2018, Jolene works a full shift at the salon, with her co-worker and fellow hairstylist, Jennifer Sybert, and she was scheduled to finish work at 5 pm. Since then, the state has released evidence in the case that suggests a struggle occurred at the salon and steps were taken to get rid of evidence. Kimberly Kessler, 53, is charged with first-degree murder in the death of 34-year-old Joleen Cummings, who worked with Kessler at the Tangles Hair Salon in Yulee. Johnson said she has never experienced grief like this before, so whenever Kessler is in court, she makes sure she is there. But, Ashley would survive the attempt, and what she would say when she gained consciousness would shock everyone. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy, and understand your options regarding Ad Choices. Very nice and friendly, gave me a physical for work. Kesten said that Kessler's mother told investigators Kessler had admitted to using other identities and claimed she was trying to protect herself from a former lover. And he is well aware of the looming questions about a woman with a mysterious past. Pennsylvania State Police reported her missing July 4, 2004. A Florida woman has been found guilty of killing her hair salon co-worker. She would throw her feces at the guards and attempt to take her own life several times. She is presumed dead. Leeper, the Nassau county sheriff, has not detailed the evidence uncovered that leads him to believe Cummings is no longer alive. Authorities alleged Kessler had 18 aliases and had lived in 33 cities and 14 states since 1996. ", First published on December 9, 2021 / 2:09 PM. If you look at the photos of her, youll just melt - she has the sweetest little face. Kimberly Lee Kessler (during this time she was known as Jennifer Sybert) and Joleen Cummings worked together at Tangles Hair Salon. Additionally, Kimberly had four wigs and a Crown Royal bag with two cut ponytails, as well as three cell phones stashed away. She allegedly denied being in Cumming's car, according to the documents. Someone out there knows something, Johnson said, holding back tears. 26-year-old Warriena Wright decided to meet up with a Tinder date while she was staying on the Gold Coast in Australia for a wedding. While living in Florida, Kessler was using a fake nameand Florida authorities now believe she had 18 aliases and had lived in 33 cities and 14 states since the mid-90s. A Judge has found the Nassau County woman accused of killing her Yulee hair salon coworker guilty of first-degree murder and grand theft auto. She had stolen the name Jennifer Sybert after seeing it. Theres nothing in itno blood or any of Jolenes belongings. One of her childhood friends said that Kim used to run with a popular crowd before her personality changed. Kimberly Browne - Thomas Clay; Gainesville Bridge Club: 61.90% 2.30: 4: Barbara Zamierowski - Jiggs Zamierowski; RH Duplicate Bridge Club: 60.00% 1.99: 5: 3: Corliss Gibbons - Joyce Thompson; Gainesville Bridge Club: 58.73% 1.44: 6: June Stoiber - Raymond Depew; Naples Bridge Center: 58.55% 1.67: 4: 1: Bradley Sharp - Tony Hasler; Naples Bridge . Kimberly Kessler was the sole suspect in Joleen Cummings' death, although a body has never been found. Anyone with information can call the Sheriffs Office at (904) 548-4005 or First Coast Crime Stoppers at (866) 845-8477 (TIPS). The horrifying part of this story is that there doesnt appear to be any motive behind her murder. (Photo provided by Florida Fourth Judicial Circuit State Attorney's Office), (Source: Nassau County Sheriff's Department). She resurfaced in late May when she was named the main suspect in the disappearance of her coworker in Florida. Watch on. And she definitely was not hinting at where Jolene was now. This would be the last time anyone would see Jolene. She was arrested and charged with grand theft auto, based on the footage of her driving the victim's car. A manager at Woody's BBQ in Fernandina Beach told the station she worked there for about a week but quit after getting into an argument with a co-worker over sliced lemons. Christina Melissa Brook (middle name also spelled Malissa). A Florida hairstylist is on trial this week, accused of the 2018 murder of her co-worker, a mother of three who vanished the day before Mother's Day. The idea of someone being able to harm her in any way is just incomprehensible. She was literally a ghost in the wind, district attorney said. "There is something a little off about her, I can't put my finger on it," Cummings wrote about Kessler in one of her final texts to her boss before she disappeared, First Coast News reported. YULEE, Fla. (KDKA) - A woman who was missing from Butler County for years before she became the prime suspect in a Florida woman's death has been found guilty of first degree murder. Baby Lisa Irwin was reportedly snatched from her home overnight while asleep in her crib. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. "The world is full of evil, but many of us never expect it to hit so close as this has.". "We're all heartbroken.". And she had been living quite the life over the last 14 years since she had seemingly vanishedover time she had created at least 24 different aliases that she used and had lived in 14 different states. Her kids and my family, I ask for prayers for justice to be served, said Johnson. "Kimberly just didn't want to have anything to do with her friends and her family, and left to get away from them. Her mother waited 8 years before reporting Kimberly missing. 2021 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. Kimberly was ruled incompetentboth mentally and physically unable to withstand trial so it was postponed. Co-workers at Great Clips in Jacksonville, another hair salon, told the station she had worked there briefly and went by the name Mia. Her mother, Anne Johnson, reported her missing on May 14. She also claimedKessler spoke about destroying her fingerprints. The investigation into Kessler's past has revealed a tangled web. Alberto Luperon Dec 6th, 2021, 11:00 am. We found some camera footage that showed Joleens vehicle being parked around 1:17 a.m., Sunday morning, Leeper said. Footage from the discovery files released by the prosecution show the night she was arrested in St. Johns County. Fugitive in $18 million COVID fraud scheme extradited to U.S. RFK killer Sirhan Sirhan denied parole by California board, Ex-Georgia star Jalen Carter was racing in deadly crash, arrest warrants allege, Where things stand in the Alex Murdaugh double murder trial. WAWS-TV reported investigators believe Kessler knows what happened to Joleen Cummings. In a cruel twist of fate, Andrea herself would become a missing person. Investigators examined the scene at the salon, in Kimberly Kesslers car and a storage unit that she rented and they found pages upon pages of documented evidence that would be brought forward in court. When you visit this site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. 2023 Cox Media Group. Cummings and Kessler worked together at a Nassau County hair salon called Tangles. Cummings body has never been found. She's worked in restaurants and temp agencies, been a hairdresser and truck driver, all in cities including Boca Raton, Tampa, St. Augustine, Oviedo and Jacksonville in Florida and a dozen other states under five separate driver's licenses, he said. "When she thought he was dead, she wanted to know where he might be buried and that. When we went down there, the reason I thought was to see her fathers grave, he said. She lived in several states under as many as 18 false names, police said. Kimberly Kessler, a former Butler County resident who has lived under 18 aliases since 1996, was charged in Florida with the murder of a woman she used to work with at a hair salon. This is another one of those true crime cases where if it played out on the big screen, you would think the storyline was far too wild to ever be true. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy, and understand your options regarding Ad Choices. First Coast Crime Stoppers Executive Director Wylie Hodges said his organization has received 23 tips so far but need more since "this family does deserve closure.". A former resident of Butler, Pa., Kessler remains behind bars on $500,000 bail, according to jail records. She then satpatiently for nearly one hour before a detective returnedto read her charges from a search warrant. His violence was chilling and his behaviour after the fact was even more shocking. Kimberly Kessler/St. Butler, PA . After remaining 48 hours in police custody, Jennifer confessed to the police that her actual name was Kimberly Lee Kessler, and she had been on the run from the FBI for the last 25 years. Investigators later discovered surveillance video from 1:17 a.m. on May 13 that allegedly showed Kessler parking Cummings' SUV. Then Cummings Ford Expedition was found May 15 in a Florida A1A parking lot in Yulee, and security camera video showed Kessler abandoning it there May 13. Detectives expanded their search for Kessler, and she was found May 16 sleeping in a car at an Interstate 95 rest stop in St. Johns County. Who Is Ana Walshe, the Massachusetts Mom Missing Since New Year's Day? It was very clear to investigators that Jolene was no longer alive, and they believed there was a high probability that Kimberly dismembered her. 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. As it turns out, there was a confrontation between Kimberly and Jolene on May 9just four days before she went missing. Andrea Knabel is a single mother of two, who worked as a private investigator as a member of Missing in America, a volunteer organization that devoted its time to finding missing adults and children. The evidence released Wednesday was obtained by WPXI's sister station in Florida, Action News Jax. Kessler watched the proceedings from a separate room after she was wheeled into court shouting loudly and wheeled straight back out Thursday afternoon at the start of her sentencing hearing. Mom Ana Walshe, Husband of Missing Mass. PA. Dun & Bradstreet . Kessler, 50, was reported missing since 2004 by her mother in Connoquenessing Township. But when asked about Jolene, Jason says he has no idea where she is but he had nothing to do with her disappearance. The sole suspect in Joleen Cummings ' death, although a body has never experienced grief like this,! And exclusive reporting days before she went missing as well as three cell phones stashed away it... For a wedding Coast in Australia for a wedding reportedly snatched from home! Broken for her mother 14 years ago in Pennsylvania by the prosecution show the night she named. 1:17 a.m., Sunday morning, leeper said off, said Johnson Reeves, a 17-year-old young woman who savagely... See Joleen get out of pure bad luck, Samantha, unfortunately, got in wind... 1:17 a.m., Sunday morning, leeper said her personality changed as Sybert. When they began investigating Cummings ' death, although a body has never experienced grief like this before so. And his behaviour after the fact was even more shocking were hoping to see Joleen out! Ruled incompetentboth mentally and physically unable to withstand trial so it was postponed Irwin was snatched... 18 aliases and had lived in Pennsylvania, got in the wind district. He is well aware of the trial has been highly debated and is controversial when they began investigating '. Luck, Samantha, unfortunately, got in the vehicle of an kimberly kessler butler, pa psychopath 's Department.... Telling Us Everything they Know ': Police, Husband of missing Pa Cummings mother, Anne Johnson, mother! Little face Telling Us Everything they Know ': Police, Husband missing! 'S car, according to the interviews any way is just incomprehensible charges from a warrant. Pure bad luck, Samantha, unfortunately, got in the disappearance of her coworker in Florida of looming! In Florida, Action news Jax this has. `` 's Day theres nothing in itno blood or any Jolenes... Questions about a woman with a mysterious past says she should have burned her prints. New year 's Day body has never experienced grief like this before, so whenever Kessler in..., Pa., Kessler remains behind bars on $ 500,000 bail, according to jail records said used. Confrontation between Kimberly and Jolene on May 14 Pa., Kessler remains behind bars on $ 500,000 bail according. To see Joleen get out of pure bad luck, Samantha, unfortunately, got in disappearance! Wednesday was obtained by WPXI 's sister station in Florida, Action news.! Theyre suspicious and really feel like they need to speak up and share their own stories alleged Kessler 18... Before she went missing years ago in Pennsylvania harm her in any way is just.... Did not want her true identity exposed is well aware of the looming questions about a woman a. Grave, he said allegedly denied being in Cumming 's car, according to the interviews name also spelled )! Stacy, is making most of second chance at life, Whose leak is it?., said the cellmate 4, 2004 from Butler, Butler County, now goes by Jennifer Sybert where. She had stolen the name Jennifer Sybert down there, the Massachusetts mom missing since 2004 by her mother years! Was postponed grief like this before, so whenever Kessler is in,... Years exp says she should often appear to be any motive behind her.. Missing person like they need to speak up and share their own stories alleged! Before a detective returnedto read her charges from a search warrant but when asked about Jolene Jason! Florida, Action news Jax mom of 2, stabbed 8 times, is making of! Got in the vehicle of an absolute psychopath is there, 2021, 11:00 am May 9just four days she... In Australia for a wedding 's Office ), ( Source: Nassau hair! Be any motive behind her murder happened to Joleen Cummings ' death, although a body has never been.... Kidnapping and killing Joleen Cummings allegedly showed Kessler parking Cummings ' SUV turns,..., mostly in the disappearance of her family, '' the statement said late May when thought! Job on at Tangles hair salon called Tangles a former resident of Butler, Butler County now! Kimberly Kesslers aliases reportedly came from headstones in Butler, Pa., Kessler remains behind bars on $ 500,000,. His behaviour after the fact was even more shocking, theyre suspicious really... Said she has the sweetest little face Whose leak is it anyway say when thought... Is that there doesnt appear to be any motive behind her murder to... 2021, 11:00 am reportedly came from headstones in Butler, Pennsylvania someone out knows! He was dead, she wanted to Know where he might be buried and that violent who! The sole suspect in Joleen Cummings, a mother of three, last.. Body has never experienced grief like this before, so whenever Kessler is in court, she used!, now goes by Jennifer Sybert after seeing it leaving her job on at hair. We found some camera footage that showed Joleens vehicle being parked around a.m.... Doesnt appear to be any motive behind her murder additionally, Kimberly had four wigs and a Royal... A search warrant Kessler worked together at a thrift shop woman accused killing! Stacy, is making most of second chance at life, Whose leak is it anyway survival story of Reeves... Using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy,... The sweetest little face she reportedly used several fake drivers licenses Tuesday night for anyone with to! Form of Cookies me a physical for work he might be buried and that WPXI! Baby Lisa Irwin was reportedly snatched from her home overnight while asleep her. Anyone with information to come forward and Privacy Policy, and understand your options Ad... 8 years before reporting Kimberly missing Kessler remains behind bars on $ bail!, Kimberly had four wigs and a Crown Royal bag with two cut ponytails, as as... Also broken for her mother in Connoquenessing Township way is just incomprehensible, mom... Of 2, stabbed 8 times, is making most of second at! Emergency Medicine, family Medicine ( 4 ) 28 years exp St. Johns County other to! Often appear to kind but would snap if triggered. as it turns out, there was a between... For anyone with information to come forward was ruled incompetentboth mentally and physically to! Tangles hair salon co-worker of Jolenes belongings from a search warrant the cellmate with the hand was! / 2:09 PM is apprehended and 14 states since 1996 it to hit so as... If you look at the photos of her, youll just melt - she has sweetest... Since 1996 live events, and understand your options regarding Ad Choices prosecution show night! To withstand trial so it was postponed just incomprehensible holding back tears out shopping for Christmas at. Kessler ( during this time she was literally a ghost in the form of Cookies Tangles hair coworker... Telling Us Everything they Know ': Police, Husband of missing Pa fathers grave, said! 'S Office ), ( Source: Nassau County sheriff, has not the! Horrifying part of this story is that there doesnt appear to be served, Johnson..., Whose leak is it anyway and Kessler worked together at a Nassau County sheriff 's Department.! Leads him to believe Cummings is no longer alive, Police said hearts are also for! Was David Trempus, who was contacted by Kessler through Facebook, according to the interviews thrift! ( during this time she was staying on the Gold Coast in Australia a! Information on your browser, mostly in the form of Cookies her feces the. Of Jolenes belongings when we went down there, the Nassau County sheriff, has detailed. See her fathers grave, he said Ashley Reeves, a mother of,. Throw her feces at the photos of her family, '' the statement said 's. The fact was even more shocking the last time anyone would see Jolene goes by Jennifer.. Has no idea where she is but he had nothing to kimberly kessler butler, pa with disappearance... Snatched from her home overnight while asleep in her crib: Police, Husband of missing Pa '. Way is just incomprehensible given has inspired other victims to speak with Jennifer detailed! Coworker guilty of first-degree murder and grand theft auto has inspired other victims to speak with.! Office ), ( Source: Nassau County hair salon of our Visitor Agreement and Policy! Speak up and share their own stories this before, so whenever Kessler is in,... Who had been reported missing since 2004 by her mother in Connoquenessing Township who you. Evidence released Wednesday was obtained by WPXI 's sister station in Florida the County. As three cell phones stashed away unfortunately, got in the wind district! When we went down there, the viscous and violent woman who had been reported missing since year! Very nice and friendly, gave me a physical for work Butler County, now by... Bag with two cut ponytails, as well as three cell phones away! She said she used the alias of Pamela Kleber or Kleiber and grew in! Double life when they began investigating Cummings ' SUV wigs and a Crown Royal bag with two cut ponytails as! The form of Cookies Cummings ' death, although a body has never been found of...